Procedure to calculate the cost effectiveness of protection

Besides the need of lightning for a structure or for a service, it may be useful to ascertain the economic benefits of installing protection measures in order to reduce economic loss
  • Calculate identified risk components RX in absence of new/additional protection measures
  • Calculate annual cost of loss due to each risk component RX
  • Calculate annual cost CL of total loss in the absence of protection measures
  • Adopt the selected protection measures
  • Calculate risk components RX with selected protection measures present
  • Calculate annual cost of residual loss due to each risk component RX in the protected structure or service
  • Calculate total annual cost CRL of residual loss with selected protection measures present
  • Calculate annual cost CPM of selected protection measures [CPM = CP x (i+a+m)]* Compare costs
  • If CL < CRL + CPM, lightning protection may not be deemed to be cost effective
  • If CL > CRL + CPM, protection measures may prove to save money over the life of the structure
Note:
CP – cost of protection measures
i – interest rate
a – amortization rate
m – maintenance rate